Below, I have cut & pasted an article from the current Latitude 38 e-mag.
The article reports on new Coast Guard requirements for races in SF Bay & ocean races that start in the Bay, such as the SHTP.
In the last 12 months, in SF Double Handed races, 2 sailors have drowned and 3 boats have been lost.
There are now 5 Minis in the Bay area & we may have a W coast race, or a class in an existing race, next year that will likely include a start, stop-over or finish in the Bay.
One positive outcome is that a future Mini race would have Coast Guard monitoring and the presence of a cutter, somewhere at sea, in closer proximity than has been the case for prior races.
New Ocean Racing Recommendations
April 22, 2009 – The Ocean
On Monday evening, five members of Coast Guard Sector San Francisco met with representatives of the YRA and any local yacht club or other organization that runs ocean races. The subject matter: making ocean racing safer. Lots of people seem to have heard different variations on what was discussed. We were there, so here are some clarifications.
* All ocean races will now require individual permits. (Bay races, which tend to have a better safety record, will continue to be given ‘blanket’ permits.) And ocean races lasting more than a day will require separate permit numbers. While this sounds onerous for an event like the Singlehanded TransPac, which might last three weeks, in actuality you would have one permit with 20-21 separate numbers in the upper righthand corner — each number representing a new day. No big deal.
* Much was made of better communications between the Coast Guard and race organizers. For example, from now on, all organizations running ocean races will need to call the Coast Guard at the start, at the finish (accounting for all boats that started, whether they finished or dropped out), and every four hours while the race is underway — even if all their boats are out of VHF range or halfway across the Pacific. The Coast Guard also pressed for individual identification sheets to be filled out by each boat in each race. These would include a description and photo of the boat, names and ages of all crew, etc. While this might sound outlandish to some, the Coasties gave a sobering example of what they sometimes deal with — a boat had called for help during an ocean race and the helo was launched. However, the pilot and crew weren’t sailors so didn’t know one ‘white 35-ft sailboat’ from another. As a result, they flew down next to several boats that sort of fit the description, including some that would instantly be ‘wrong’ to a sailor — like a WylieCat if you were looking for a sloop — and asked each one if they were the boat that called. Luckily, the boat in trouble turned out to be okay, but the problem is obvious.
* Barring other missions or emergencies, a Coast Guard cutter will now be out in the ocean for every local ocean race. The ship will either shadow the largest clump of boats or hang out near danger areas of the course, such as the bar. This was done for the first time during last weekend’s Crewed Farallones Race. Participants might not have seen the cutter, but it was there.
* The Coast Guard will be drafting a regulation asking that ocean racers be required to carry EPIRBs starting in calendar year 2010. This regulation has not yet been written, so exactly what kind of an EPIRB would qualify is unclear. However, the Coast Guard Captain at the meeting felt confident it would be a Cat 1 (float free) 406 similar to the ones fishing boats carry. Once the reg is written, it would go through the normal public comment process and evaluation, which takes several months. However, YRA President Pat Broderick announced at the meeting that OYRA would require boats to carry EPIRBs starting with the 2010 season.
Overall, the meeting was much more courteous than contentious, and the main Coast Guard position seemed to be ‘help us help you.’ In response to questions regarding PLBs (personal locator beacons), DSC (digital selective calling) buttons on VHFs and so on, the answer was almost always “Anything that makes you safer is a good thing.”
Would this meeting and new regulations ever have happened if three boats and two sailors had not been lost in ocean races over the past 12 months? Probably not. Ironically, Daisy (lost with her two crew during the 2008 Doublehanded Lightship), Pterodactyl (two crew thrown out during the ‘08 Doublehanded Farallones; they were rescued but could not get back aboard or recover the boat later; it sails on as a derelict), and Heat Wave (lost a keel and capsized during last month’s Doublehanded Farallones, both crew rescued) would not have benefited from a float-free EPIRB, which does not transmit underwater or from inside the boat.
The bottom line: there are no panaceas when it comes to safety. No one system — either one you take with you or one whose Search and Rescue personnel get going as soon as your boat issues a distress call — is going to insure your survival every time. But the more you have, and the more that work at peak efficiency, the better the chances that you will live to tell about any emergency that does occur.
- latitude / jr